The linked file is a ROUGH DRAFT of the appearance scoring checklist and value possibles; remember we go by percentages, in terms of its impact on Ren Man and individual prizes/awards
The point here is that army is scored for overall theme and appearance on the tabletop, plus presentation and army-wide heavy conversion
One individual mini is scored for advanced painting techniques and attention to detail
One individual mini is scored for advanced conversion techniques
Armies, minis, and converted minis that score max or very close to it will be entered into final consideration for the individual army/mini/conversion prizes
Judges will all be on the same page with regard to scoring, and any army that scores exceptionally low or high will be reviewed by another judge for integrity
Let me know via E-MAIL - MVBRANDT@GMAIL.COM ... WHAT YOU THINK.
This'll get published tomorrow, I have a lot of private contacts heads'ed up for feedback as well.
APPEARANCE SCORING DRAFT V1